Extreme Choice filly tops HTBA May Sale with new record

10 min read
A filly by Extreme Choice from the draft of Bell River Thoroughbreds became the highest priced Inglis HTBA May Yearling Sale purchase in history when realising $300,000 to the bid of Michael Freedman at Riverside on Sunday.

Cover image courtesy of Inglis

At A Glance

The average for the Sale, previously known as the Scone Yearling Sale, increased to $25,271 up from $19,202 in 2021 and $17,566 in 2020.

The median also climbed to $17,000, having been $14,000 (2021) and $10,000 (2020).

The overall Sale aggregate was $5.382 million from 213 horses sold, up from $5.05 million last year, where 263 horses sold.

The clearance rate stood at 82 per cent after the final lot went through the ring.

A filly by Extreme Choice became the highest priced purchase in the Sale's history when realising $300,000 to the bid of Michael Freedman.

The second highest price of the Sale was Lot 221, a colt by Epaulette, who was purchased by David Pfieffer and Oliver Koolman for $120,000, while it was a four-way tie for the third highest price of the Sale, with four colts by Harry Angel (Ire), Capitalist, Divine Prophet and Hellbent, respectively, each bringing $100,000.

Six yearlings, a filly and five colts, broke the three-figure barrier, up from two last year.

Freedman banking on a proven formula

Michael Freedman, who has experienced G1 Golden Slipper S. success with the progeny of Extreme Choice via Stay Inside’s victory in last year’s edition, has added another prospect by Newgate Farms’s sire of the moment to his arsenal. He went to a Sale-topping and Sale record-breaking $300,000 to secure Lot 57, a filly from the draft of Bell River Thoroughbreds.

Freedman said the filly was his number one priority going into the Sale and that she profiles like a late autumn 2-year-old that will furnish into a lovely 3-year-old.

Lot 57 - Extreme Choice x Dashie Diva (filly) | Image courtesy of Inglis

He believes the filly was well bought, saying she could’ve potentially sold for more money if entered in a more ‘high-profile’ sale.

“She was a good, athletic type, a good-moving filly and I think being an October foal she’s probably unlikely to necessarily be an early pre-Christmas type,” Freedman told TDN AusNZ.

“But once she physically fills into that frame of her she will be a nice individual and in the context of how the Extreme Choices have gone this year, I don’t think it was crazy type of money.”

"...once she (Lot 57) physically fills into that frame of hers she will be a nice individual and in the context of how the Extreme Choices have gone this year, I don’t think it was crazy type of money.” - Michael Freedman

Freedman, who is now based at Randwick after recently dissolving a successful partnership with his brother Richard, also secured a colt by Merchant Navy for $45,000.

He said Lot 48 was purchased for the right price and that he is a ‘good, strong colt’ who will come into his own as a 3-year-old.

“I’m still a believer in the stallion, I certainly think given the profile of the horse as a racehorse and his pedigree that I’m still happy to shop around for the right types by him,” Freedman said.

Michael Freedman | Image courtesy of Inglis

Extremely rewarding result

Bell River Thoroughbreds' Andrew Ferguson, who sold the Sale-topping Extreme Choice filly, was delighted by the outcome, after seeing the offspring of Dashie Diva (Dash For Cash) successfully overcome the removal of a chip from her hind fetlock that ruled her out of February’s Inglis Classic Sale.

“I always thought this filly was probably her (Dashie Diva’s) best foal, very similar to dad, and Luke Wilkinson, who bought Extreme Choice, and I were comparing their yearling photos this morning and saying how she’s just the same shape and make to him,” Ferguson told TDN AusNZ.

“Luke Wilkinson, who bought Extreme Choice, and I were comparing their yearling photos this morning and saying how she’s (Lot 57) just the same shape and make to him.” - Andrew Ferguson

“Sebastian Hutch assured me that he’ll get the buyers here, and said bring her to this Sale and you’ll get your money, so I trusted Sebastian and today we got the result, so it worked out well as she had some good judges on her and made her money.”

Ferguson, who bred Extreme Choice and purchased the dual-winning Dashie Diva for $13,000 as a weanling in 2005, said Sunday’s result was rather emotional, with Dashie Diva passing this year.

Extreme Choice | Standing at Newgate Farm

Dashie Diva, whose seven foals to race have all won, is responsible for the Listed Nitschke S.-winning East Indiaman (Hinchinbrook).

Ferguson said the decision to send Dashie Diva to Extreme Choice was based on the quality of the mare’s first foal Dee Dee Flyer, a city-winning son of Not A Single Doubt that never got to realise his true potential due to injury.

“It’s a little bit emotional today as Dashie Diva was one of the first mares that we had when we started and having bred Extreme (Choice) that no one really wanted to go to when he first started at stud,” Ferguson said.

Jock, Andrew and James Ferguson | Image courtesy of Bell River Thoroughbreds

“We lost the mare this year, so that’s her last foal and Michael (Freedman) has allowed us to keep a little share in her, so we’re going to enjoy racing the last one out of her.”

Ferguson reflected on Extreme Choice’s record breaking start to his stud career with immense pride.

“Us as a family, my wife Georgie and the boys (James and Jock), are bursting with pride that we bred something like that, and we are lucky enough to have a breeding right in him and four weanlings at home by him in the paddock,” Ferguson said.

“Us as a family, my wife Georgie and the boys (James and Jock), are bursting with pride that we bred something like that (Extreme Choice), and we are lucky enough to have a breeding right in him and four weanlings at home by him in the paddock.” - Andrew Ferguson

“It’s been a hell of a journey with him, I’m immensely proud, and proud of the job Newgate are doing with him under very difficult circumstances, and at this stage I have Prophet’s Thumb pencilled in to go to him this season.”

Hutch stoked by extremely successful Sale

Sebastian Hutch, Inglis Bloodstock CEO, was delighted by the strength of the Sale, which is beginning to grow in stature, saying they were pleased by the overall quality of the catalogue, bolstered by the $300,000 Extreme Choice filly who was initially set to make an impression at the Inglis Classic Yearling Sale in February.

He said the current clearance rate of 82 per cent is a clear indication that buyers at a variety of different levels were impressed by the stock on offer.

“We were optimistic that we would run a good Sale, I don’t think you can ever expect as good a Sale as it turned out today but there was strong interest in the Sale and we were pleased with nature of representation,” Hutch told TDN AusNZ.

“To grow the vendor base to farms like Coolmore, Segenhoe and Widden added a level of strength that mightn’t have been there in the past to attract a really strong buying bench.

“To grow the vendor base to farms like Coolmore, Segenhoe and Widden added a level of strength that mightn’t have been there in the past to attract a really strong buying bench." - Sebastian Hutch

“It is a Sale that we have a lot of belief in and fortunately we’ve been able to generate some good results.”

Hutch said he is reluctant to speculate on whether the Sale can continue to trend upwards due to the ‘unpredictably of the business’.

“For as long as people want to sell at this Sale we will be doing everything we can to generate good results for them,” Hutch said.

Sebastian Hutch | Image courtesy of Inglis

“And on the back of the Sale that we’ve had this year, people can look at this Sale in 2023 as a Sale they can approach with a level of confidence that we will be managing it in the same professional manner that we do with any other Sale.”

Epaulette colt takes second position

The second top price of the day, $120,000, was paid by trainer David Pfeiffer and Oliver Koolman of Waratah Thoroughbreds for Lot 221, a colt by Epaulette.

Offered by Goodwood Farm, the colt is the third living foal out of the winning Sebring mare Rosa’s Magic, making him a brother to the city-winning filly Military Magic.

Lot 221 - Epaulette x Rosa's Magic (colt) | Image courtesy of Inglis

Neil and Denise Osborne’s Mane Lodge, which recently set an Inglis Classic Sale record when a colt by Extreme Choice brought $825,000, struck gold again, with two of their colts each selling for $100,000.

Lot 92, a colt by Darley shuttle stallion Harry Angel (Ire) was knocked down to David Payne while Paul Perry secured the Capitalist colt for the same sum.

A colt by Divine Prophet from the draft of Bowness Stud also realised $100,000 when secured by Matt Chidgey, who has had success with the progeny of Divine Prophet, having bred G2 Skyline S. hero Promitto.

Lot 247, a colt by Yarraman Park’s first-season stallion Hellbent from the draft of Segenhoe Thoroughbreds, also realised three figures when knocked down to Kurrinda Bloodstock and Singleton Racing for $100,000.

Gallery: Mane Lodge struck gold with two yearlings selling for $100,000 at the HTBA May Yearling Sale, images courtesy of Inglis

Big week just beginning

Attention now turns to the Inglis Australian Weanling Sale which begins on Wednesday; Friday evening will then host the Inglis Chairman’s Sale and features an abundance of high-class race fillies and mares such as Shout The Bar (Not A Single Doubt) and Daysee Doom (Domesday).

The Inglis Australian Broodmare Sale will conclude a big week of selling at Riverside next Sunday.

“We are very pleased with the number and variety of weanlings in the weanling catalogue, there’s 418 catalogued by 94 individual stallions and it gives buyers at all levels looking for a variety of different options a great range of choice,” Hutch said.

"...there’s 418 catalogued (in the Inglis Australian Weanling Sale) by 94 individual stallions and it gives buyers at all levels looking for a variety of different options a great range of choice.” - Sebastian Hutch

“The Chairman’s Sale looks very strong, there’s some high-quality mares and we’ve had some great supplementaries and there’s something there for people at all price levels.”

Hutch believes the scheduling of four sales within a seven day block works well.

“We’re conscious of trying to run a sequence of sales that is time and cost efficient for our vendors, as we appreciate that bringing horses to any sale is an expensive exercise,” Hutch said.

“The feedback we have had from vendors is that the schedule works well.”

Top lots

57fillyExtreme ChoiceDashie DivaMichael Freedman Racing Pty Ltd NSWMichael Freedman Racing Pty Ltd NSW$300,000
221ColtEpauletteRosa's MagicGoodwood Farm, MurrurundiDavid Pfieffer Racing / Oliver Koolman / Dragon Bloodstock NSW$120,000
92ColtHarry Angel Fervent DelightMane Lodge, SuttonPayne Racing Pty Ltd NSW$100,000
101ColtCapitalistFor Me DadMane Lodge, SuttonPaul Perry Horse Training Pty Ltd NSW$100,000
199ColtDivine ProphetPedimentBowness Stud, YoungM Chidgey NSW$100,000
247ColtHellbentSpurs and SashesSegenhoe Thoroughbreds Aust Pty Ltd, SconeKurrinda Bloodstock / Singleton Racing NSW$100,000
69ColtBull PointDollhouseKingstar Farm, DenmanTrilogy Racing Pty Ltd NSW$85,000
143ColtRussian RevolutionLady AntebellumKingstar Farm, DenmanArrow Park Bloodstock NSW$80,000
162ColtHeadwaterMadame ZaraVinery Stud, SconePaul Moroney / Catheryne Bruggeman / CJG Racing NSW$75,000
168ColtDundeel MarquardtKingstar Farm, DenmanTal Nolen VIC$75,000

Top buyers

Paul Perry Horse Training Pty Ltd8$391,500$48,938$100,000
Michael Freedman Racing Pty Ltd2$345,000$172,500$300,000
Joseph & Jones Racing8$229,000$28,625$57,500
M Chidgey2$200,000$100,000$100,000
Trilogy Racing Pty Ltd3$195,000$65,000$85,000
T Bateup9$179,000$19,889$32,000
Arrow Park Bloodstock2$160,000$80,000$80,000
Moffatt Breaking & Pre Training3$155,000$51,667$62,500
Paul Moroney / Catheryne Bruggeman / CJG Racing2$150,000$75,000$75,000
Tal Nolen2$150,000$75,000$75,000

Vendors by aggregate

Kingstar Farm, Denman16$703,500$43,969$85,000
Vinery Stud, Scone21$653,500$31,119$75,000
Twin Hills Stud, Cootamundra12$480,500$40,042$70,000
Mane Lodge, Sutton9$476,000$52,889$100,000
Segenhoe Thoroughbreds Aust Pty Ltd, Scone9$369,000$41,000$100,000
Widden Stud, Widden Valley16$362,500$22,656$57,500
Holbrook Thoroughbreds, Scone16$348,500$21,781$62,500
Bowness Stud, Young17$337,000$19,824$100,000
Bell River Thoroughbreds, Glen William3$328,000$109,333$300,000
Coolmore Stud, Jerrys Plains10$318,000$31,800$70,000

Vendors by average (3 or more sold)

Bell River Thoroughbreds, Glen William3$328,000$109,333$300,000
Mane Lodge, Sutton9$476,000$52,889$100,000
Kingstar Farm, Denman16$703,500$43,969$85,000
Segenhoe Thoroughbreds Aust Pty Ltd, Scone9$369,000$41,000$100,000
Twin Hills Stud, Cootamundra12$480,500$40,042$70,000
Ashleigh Thoroughbreds, Scone4$128,500$32,125$42,500
Coolmore Stud, Jerrys Plains10$318,000$31,800$70,000
Vinery Stud, Scone21$653,500$31,119$75,000
HP Thoroughbreds, Hilldale6$176,000$29,333$50,000
Riversdale, Scone9$256,500$28,500$42,000

Sires by aggregate

Divine Prophet10$448,000$44,800$100,000
Headwater12$429,500$35,792$75,000
Capitalist8$397,000$49,625$100,000
Extreme Choice1$300,000$300,000$300,000
Super One17$291,000$17,118$50,000
Press Statement14$283,000$20,214$36,000
Russian Revolution7$271,000$38,714$80,000
Bull Point12$255,000$21,250$85,000
Rubick16$250,250$15,641$37,500
Smart Missile7$245,000$35,000$70,000

Sires by average (2 or more sold)

Dundeel 2$150,000$75,000$75,000
Harry Angel 3$194,500$64,833$100,000
Ribchester 2$120,000$60,000$60,000
Per Incanto2$100,000$50,000$50,000
Capitalist8$397,000$49,625$100,000
Divine Prophet10$448,000$44,800$100,000
Hellbent4$178,000$44,500$100,000
Exosphere3$130,000$43,333$55,000
Epaulette4$172,000$43,000$120,000
Russian Revolution7$271,000$38,714$80,000
Inglis HTBA May Yearling Sale
Extreme Choice
Michael Freedman
Dashie Diva
Bell River Thoroughbreds
Mane Lodge
Sebastian Hutch
Andrew Ferguson
Epaulette
Harry Angel
Capitalist